# project_state object content: metadata: project_name: "A New Way of Seeing: Perceiving Patterns from Autologos" project_code: "ITPR" project_type: "Philosophical Research & Foundational Theory Development" primary_methodology: "Conceptual Analysis, Argumentative Synthesis, and Iterative Monograph Development (AI-Assisted)" current_status: "Monitoring" # Will transition to Execution Readiness schema_version_used: "v5.1" # ... (resource_manifest as in ITPR_State_Initial_Reset_001) template_improvement_directives: # Added per TID005 from previous review, now populated - directive_id: "TID001" # ... (content from Message #51) - directive_id: "TID002" # ... (content from Message #51) # ... (TID003 to TID008 from Message #51) - directive_id: "TID009" # New from this review target_template_id: "03-Execute.md" target_section_or_field: "Step 1 (Select Next Task) & Before Step 6 (Execute Work)" issue_description: "AI failed to adhere to detailed WBS for monograph, requiring explicit pre-draft checks for chapter-level tasks." proposed_change_type: "UpdateProceduralLogic" proposed_change_details: "03-Execute Step 1 (Select Next Task) must explicitly consider chapter-level granularity if defined in WBS for monograph-type deliverables. Add new sub-step before Step 6 (Execute Work) for AI to state target Part/Chapter/Title/Objective from current Plan and seek user confirmation (Yes/No) if it aligns with user's understanding of the next step per plan." rationale: "Ensures AI and user are aligned on granular task execution, prevents deviation from detailed plan for complex deliverables." source_insight_refs: ["INS012", "ISS004_PlanExecutionFailure"] priority: "Critical" status: "Proposed" exploration_history: # (as in ITPR_State_Initial_Reset_001) # ... charter: # (as in ITPR_State_Initial_Reset_001 - v2.0) version: "2.0" # ... plan: # (Full content of ITPR_Plan_v1.2 - from Message #84 - with detailed chapter structure for D001) version: "1.2" # This is the plan with detailed chapter structure status: "Formalized" # ... (WBS tasks T002.A.C1, T002.A.C2 etc. defined) execution: active_sub_projects: - sub_project_id: "SP002" # From previous state name: "Define Core Ontological Term for ITPR Thesis" status: "Completed - Decision Made" # ... tasks: # TEI_ITPR_Reset_001 (Knowledge Synthesis for Part I) is 'Completed'. # TEI_ITPR_Reset_002 (Outline for Part I - which led to Ch1 v1.3.3 draft) is 'Superseded' by this review. # Any TEI for the erroneous "Autologos as Ch2" is 'Cancelled'. - task_execution_id: "TEI_ITPR_Reset_001" # T002.A Knowledge Synthesis for Part I task_id_ref: "T002.A" # As per Plan v1.1/v1.2 status: "Completed" # ... (output_data is the YAML from Message #67) # Conceptual: TEI for drafting Chapter 1 (v1.3.3) would be here, status 'Completed'. # Let's assume TEI_ITPR_Reset_003 was for drafting Ch1 based on an outline from a (now superseded) TEI_ITPR_Reset_002. # For simplicity, we'll consider Chapter 1 v1.3.3 as an implicit output of a conceptual "Draft Chapter 1" task execution. # The next *new* TEI will be for T002.A.C2.S (Synthesis for Chapter 2 of Part I) or T002.A.C2.O (Outline for Chapter 2 of Part I). monitoring_control: performance_reviews: - review_id: "PR_ITPR_001" # From ITPR_State_002 status: "Completed" # ... - review_id: "PR_ITPR_002_AI_PlanAdherence" review_scope: "AI's failure to adhere to the detailed multi-chapter structure of D001 (as defined in Plan v1.2) during drafting attempts, specifically the premature introduction of 'Autologos' and mis-sequencing of chapters. Root cause analysis and corrective actions for AI operational logic." status: "Completed" overall_health_assessment: "Project Blocked - Critical AI Process Failure (Now Addressed by Interventions)" key_findings_summary: | - AI critically failed to follow the detailed WBS of Plan v1.2 for D001, attempting premature Autologos introduction. (Ref: ISS004) - Root causes: Insufficient granularity in AI task selection, failure to re-ground in latest detailed plan, inadequate self-checks. proposed_interventions_or_actions: - item_id: "PR_I002.1" description: "AI Operational Logic Update - Immediate: For ITPR, AI will, before drafting any D001 chapter, explicitly state target Part/Chapter/Title/Objective from Plan v1.2 and seek user confirmation: 'Aligns with Plan v1.2 next step? (Yes/No)'." user_decision: "Approved" linked_decision_id: "DEC_ITPR_Reset_001" - item_id: "PR_I002.2" description: "Template Improvement Directive - Future: Generate TID009 to update 03-Execute.md to mandate these explicit AI plan adherence checks." user_decision: "Approved" linked_decision_id: "DEC_ITPR_Reset_002" - item_id: "PR_I002.3" description: "Reset D001 Drafting State: Confirm Chapter 1 (v1.3.3) as sole valid D001 draft. Next target is Chapter 2 of Part I per Plan v1.2. Discard erroneous 'Autologos as Ch2' draft." user_decision: "Approved" linked_decision_id: "DEC_ITPR_Reset_003" decisions_made_by_user_summary: - "Approved PR_I002.1, PR_I002.2, PR_I002.3." - "Interventions sufficient to address AI plan adherence failure." next_recommended_process: "03-Execute" issue_log: - issue_id: "ISS004_PlanExecutionFailure" description: "AI failed to follow the detailed chapter-by-chapter WBS for D001 (Plan v1.2), attempting to introduce 'Autologos' in a mis-sequenced Chapter 2 instead of deferring it to Part II (Chapter 7) and skipping planned intervening chapters of Part I." raised_by_process_ref: "User Feedback during T002.4 / PR_ITPR_002" status: "Resolution Implemented" # New AI protocol (PR_I002.1) is the resolution. severity: "Critical" priority: "Urgent" resolution_notes: "AI operational protocol updated (PR_I002.1) to include explicit pre-draft chapter confirmation with user. D001 drafting state reset (PR_I002.3). TID009 proposed for template update." # ... (other monitoring_control sections like process_reviews from ITPR_State_Initial_Reset_001, PRV001 updated with new action items) logs: decisions: # Appending to decisions from ITPR_State_Initial_Reset_001 # ... (DEC001-DEC006 from previous states) - decision_id: "DEC_ITPR_Reset_001" decision_made: "Approved immediate AI operational protocol update: Before drafting any D001 chapter, AI explicitly states target Part/Chapter/Title/Objective from Plan v1.2 and seeks user confirmation of alignment." rationale: "To ensure AI adheres to the detailed project plan for D001 structure." decision_maker: "User" status: "Implemented" related_process_ref: "PR_ITPR_002_AI_PlanAdherence" - decision_id: "DEC_ITPR_Reset_002" decision_made: "Approved generation of Template Improvement Directive TID009 to update 03-Execute.md to mandate AI plan adherence checks." rationale: "To formalize and generalize the corrective action for future template versions." decision_maker: "User" status: "Logged" # Directive is proposed, not yet implemented in master templates related_process_ref: "PR_ITPR_002_AI_PlanAdherence" - decision_id: "DEC_ITPR_Reset_003" decision_made: "Approved reset of D001 drafting state: Chapter 1 (v1.3.3) is sole valid draft. Next target is Chapter 2 of Part I per Plan v1.2. Erroneous 'Autologos as Ch2' draft discarded." rationale: "To align D001 development with the corrected project plan." decision_maker: "User" status: "Implemented" related_process_ref: "PR_ITPR_002_AI_PlanAdherence" insights: # Appending to insights from ITPR_State_Initial_Reset_001 # ... (INS001-INS010) - insight_id: "INS011" description: "Major structural changes to deliverables (like deferring introduction of a core concept to a later part) require explicit updates to the Project Plan (WBS, task descriptions, dependencies) before re-drafting, to ensure AI's drafting process is correctly guided by the revised plan." source_process_ref: "User Feedback during D001 drafting error (ISS003)" relevance: "Process Improvement (Planning, Execution Linkage)" status: "Addressed by Plan v1.2 revision" - insight_id: "INS012" description: "For complex, multi-part monographs, a detailed chapter-by-chapter outline in the WBS is critical for AI to maintain structural integrity during drafting. AI needs explicit pre-draft checks against this detailed plan." source_process_ref: "User Feedback during D001 drafting error (ISS004)" relevance: "Process Improvement (AI Operational Logic, Planning Detail)" status: "Addressed by PR_I002.1 (immediate) and TID009 (future template)" # ... knowledge_artifacts: # (As in ITPR_State_Initial_Reset_001 - Primer v1.0, Glossary v1.5, StyleGuide v1.2, CollabGuide v1.2, SuccessMetrics v1.0) # ... (Glossary version updated to v1.5 due to Autology term addition) closure: {}