# Conversation Log - Protocol v8.2 # Optimized for machine parsing and downstream AI analysis. # Emphasizes explicit extraction, structural representation, and embedded schema. # Default scope is entire available history unless specified otherwise by user. # ---- SCHEMA DEFINITION (v8.2) ---- # Root Keys: metadata, initial_trigger, turns, final_state # metadata: Keys include outline_id, source_thread_identifier, processing_datetime, scope_processed [Default: Full | Range: T_start-T_end], counts, language, protocol_version (v8.2), inferred_general_subject, protocol_applied. # Added scope_processed # initial_trigger: Keys include turn_id (T0 or T1), speaker, content. (Represents start of entire conversation) # turns: List of Turn Objects *within the processed scope*. # Turn Object: Keys include turn_id (T# - Absolute numbering from conversation start), speaker, timestamp (Optional ISO 8601), elements (List of Element Objects). # Element Object: Keys include element_id (T#_E# - Absolute numbering), element_type, extraction_confidence [High|Medium|Low], content (String - Key phrase/minimal summary), attributes (Dict), links (List of Link Objects). # Element Types & Specific Attributes: (Controlled vocabularies are case-sensitive) # Concept_Mention: attributes: { context: [Defined|Debated|Example|Mentioned], definition_source_id: [ID|Null] } # Question: attributes: { question_type: [Factual|Clarification|Hypothetical|Confirmation|Rhetorical|Open_Ended], answer_status: [Answered|Partially_Answered|Unanswered] } # Assertion: attributes: { assertion_type: [Claim|Premise|Conclusion|Definition|Observation], evidence_cited: [String|None], stance_expressed: [Supports|Opposes|Neutral|Ambivalent] [Optional: Target_ID], stance_strength: [Strong|Moderate|Weak|Unspecified], confidence_expressed: [High|Medium|Low|Speculative], argument_id: [Arg#|Null] } # Reference_Mention: attributes: { reference_type: [Video|Book|Theory|Person|Paper|URL|Dataset|Other|File], stated_purpose: [Example|Evidence|Source_Concept|Comparison|Background|Unspecified|Input_Data] } # Added File, Input_Data # Interaction_Marker: attributes: { interaction_type: [Agreement_Direct|Disagreement_Direct|Clarification_Request|Clarification_Provided|Correction_Factual|Correction_Interpretive|Self_Correction|Topic_Shift_Initiated|Topic_Shift_Accepted|Synthesis_Attempt|Question_Answer_Indicator|Acknowledgment|Hedge|Emphasis|Instruction|Apology|Approval|Request_Action], target_element_id: [ID], target_turn: [N] } # Added Instruction, Apology, Approval, Request_Action # Stated_Conclusion: attributes: { scope: [Topic_String|Sub_Thread|Overall_Thread], agreement_level: [Explicitly_Agreed|Unilaterally_Stated|Disputed] } # Stated_Unresolved_Aspect: attributes: { aspect_type: [Open_Question|Acknowledged_Limitation|Deferred_Topic|Point_of_Confusion] } # Conflict_Detected: attributes: { conflict_type: [Direct_Contradiction|Opposing_Stance] } # Links identify conflicting elements # Processing_Issue: attributes: { issue_type: [Ambiguous_Speaker|Ambiguous_Reference|Unclear_Intent|Parsing_Failure|Missing_Context|Link_Uncertainty], target_turn: [N] } # Link Object: Keys include target_id (Element ID), link_type [Responds_To|Clarifies|Counters|Supports|Premise_For_Conclusion|Conclusion_From_Premise|Builds_Upon|Elaborates_On_Concept|Seeks_Clarification_Of|Refers_To|Summarizes|Exemplifies|Conflicts_With|Analyzes|Generates|Approves|Requests_Revision_Of|...] # Added Analyzes, Generates, Approves, Requests_Revision_Of # Argument Grouping: Assertions (Premise/Conclusion) belonging to the same explicit argument share an `argument_id`. See Guideline 3.8. # final_state: Keys include open_question_ids (List), stated_conclusion_ids (List), unresolved_topic_descriptions (List), detected_conflict_ids (List), processing_issues (List of Processing_Issue Element Objects). *Reflects state at the end of the processed scope.* # ---- END SCHEMA DEFINITION ---- # ---- METADATA ---- metadata: outline_id: OUTLINE_20250430_221200_ChatLog # Example ID source_thread_identifier: "[Current Session Identifier]" processing_datetime: "2025-04-30T22:12:00Z" # Timestamp of processing scope_processed: "Full" protocol_applied: "EXTRACT-Chat_Log-Structured_v8.2" counts: { turns: 21, elements: 41 } # Calculated after processing language: "en-US" inferred_general_subject: "Interdisciplinary investigation into consciousness, emergence, subjectivity, and related topics, including analysis of provided texts and generation/refinement of a project charter (ICE)." processing_protocol_version: "v8.2" # ---- INITIAL TRIGGER ---- # Represents the actual start of the conversation, regardless of scope processed initial_trigger: turn_id: T0 speaker: User content: "User provides file 25121021159.md (Interpretation: Not Random/Deterministic)." # ---- CONVERSATIONAL TURNS ---- # Includes ONLY turns within the processed scope (default=all) turns: - turn_id: T1 speaker: User timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T1_E1 element_type: Reference_Mention extraction_confidence: High content: "Provides file 25121021159.md" attributes: { reference_type: File, stated_purpose: Input_Data } links: [] - turn_id: T2 speaker: AI timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T2_E1 element_type: Interaction_Marker extraction_confidence: High content: "Acknowledges file and summarizes content." attributes: { interaction_type: Acknowledgment } links: [ { target_id: T1_E1, link_type: Responds_To } ] - element_id: T2_E2 element_type: Assertion extraction_confidence: High content: "Summary of 25121021159.md (Not random/deterministic interpretation)." attributes: { assertion_type: Observation, evidence_cited: T1_E1, stance_expressed: Neutral, stance_strength: Unspecified, confidence_expressed: High, argument_id: Null } links: [ { target_id: T1_E1, link_type: Analyzes } ] - turn_id: T3 speaker: User timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T3_E1 element_type: Reference_Mention extraction_confidence: High content: "Provides file Brain Subjectivity and Computation." attributes: { reference_type: File, stated_purpose: Input_Data } links: [] - turn_id: T4 speaker: AI timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T4_E1 element_type: Interaction_Marker extraction_confidence: High content: "Acknowledges file and summarizes content." attributes: { interaction_type: Acknowledgment } links: [ { target_id: T3_E1, link_type: Responds_To } ] - element_id: T4_E2 element_type: Assertion extraction_confidence: High content: "Summary of Brain Subjectivity and Computation." attributes: { assertion_type: Observation, evidence_cited: T3_E1, stance_expressed: Neutral, stance_strength: Unspecified, confidence_expressed: High, argument_id: Null } links: [ { target_id: T3_E1, link_type: Analyzes } ] - turn_id: T5 speaker: User timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T5_E1 element_type: Reference_Mention extraction_confidence: High content: "Provides file Consciousness Contemplation and Transformation." attributes: { reference_type: File, stated_purpose: Input_Data } links: [] - turn_id: T6 speaker: AI timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T6_E1 element_type: Interaction_Marker extraction_confidence: High content: "Acknowledges file and summarizes content." attributes: { interaction_type: Acknowledgment } links: [ { target_id: T5_E1, link_type: Responds_To } ] - element_id: T6_E2 element_type: Assertion extraction_confidence: High content: "Summary of Consciousness Contemplation and Transformation." attributes: { assertion_type: Observation, evidence_cited: T5_E1, stance_expressed: Neutral, stance_strength: Unspecified, confidence_expressed: High, argument_id: Null } links: [ { target_id: T5_E1, link_type: Analyzes } ] - turn_id: T7 speaker: User timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T7_E1 element_type: Reference_Mention extraction_confidence: High content: "Provides file Emergent Behavior and AI Consciousness." attributes: { reference_type: File, stated_purpose: Input_Data } links: [] - turn_id: T8 speaker: AI timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T8_E1 element_type: Interaction_Marker extraction_confidence: High content: "Acknowledges file and summarizes content." attributes: { interaction_type: Acknowledgment } links: [ { target_id: T7_E1, link_type: Responds_To } ] - element_id: T8_E2 element_type: Assertion extraction_confidence: High content: "Summary of Emergent Behavior and AI Consciousness." attributes: { assertion_type: Observation, evidence_cited: T7_E1, stance_expressed: Neutral, stance_strength: Unspecified, confidence_expressed: High, argument_id: Null } links: [ { target_id: T7_E1, link_type: Analyzes } ] - turn_id: T9 speaker: User timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T9_E1 element_type: Reference_Mention extraction_confidence: High content: "Provides file Fundamental Physics and Emergence Inquiry." attributes: { reference_type: File, stated_purpose: Input_Data } links: [] - turn_id: T10 speaker: AI timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T10_E1 element_type: Interaction_Marker extraction_confidence: High content: "Acknowledges file and summarizes content." attributes: { interaction_type: Acknowledgment } links: [ { target_id: T9_E1, link_type: Responds_To } ] - element_id: T10_E2 element_type: Assertion extraction_confidence: High content: "Summary of Fundamental Physics and Emergence Inquiry." attributes: { assertion_type: Observation, evidence_cited: T9_E1, stance_expressed: Neutral, stance_strength: Unspecified, confidence_expressed: High, argument_id: Null } links: [ { target_id: T9_E1, link_type: Analyzes } ] - turn_id: T11 speaker: User timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T11_E1 element_type: Reference_Mention extraction_confidence: High content: "Provides file Reverse Inference and Brain Prediction." attributes: { reference_type: File, stated_purpose: Input_Data } links: [] - turn_id: T12 speaker: AI timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T12_E1 element_type: Interaction_Marker extraction_confidence: High content: "Acknowledges file and summarizes content." attributes: { interaction_type: Acknowledgment } links: [ { target_id: T11_E1, link_type: Responds_To } ] - element_id: T12_E2 element_type: Assertion extraction_confidence: High content: "Summary of Reverse Inference and Brain Prediction." attributes: { assertion_type: Observation, evidence_cited: T11_E1, stance_expressed: Neutral, stance_strength: Unspecified, confidence_expressed: High, argument_id: Null } links: [ { target_id: T11_E1, link_type: Analyzes } ] - turn_id: T13 speaker: User timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T13_E1 element_type: Reference_Mention extraction_confidence: High content: "Provides file Neuroscience Research Questions and Investigations." attributes: { reference_type: File, stated_purpose: Input_Data } links: [] - turn_id: T14 speaker: AI timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T14_E1 element_type: Interaction_Marker extraction_confidence: High content: "Acknowledges file and summarizes content." attributes: { interaction_type: Acknowledgment } links: [ { target_id: T13_E1, link_type: Responds_To } ] - element_id: T14_E2 element_type: Assertion extraction_confidence: High content: "Summary of Neuroscience Research Questions and Investigations." attributes: { assertion_type: Observation, evidence_cited: T13_E1, stance_expressed: Neutral, stance_strength: Unspecified, confidence_expressed: High, argument_id: Null } links: [ { target_id: T13_E1, link_type: Analyzes } ] - turn_id: T15 speaker: User timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T15_E1 element_type: Reference_Mention extraction_confidence: High content: "Provides file DEFINE-Project_Charter_v1.4.md (protocol)." attributes: { reference_type: File, stated_purpose: Input_Data } links: [] - element_id: T15_E2 element_type: Interaction_Marker extraction_confidence: High content: "Instructs AI to generate Project Charter v1.0 based on context." attributes: { interaction_type: Instruction } links: [ { target_id: T15_E1, link_type: Refers_To } ] - turn_id: T16 speaker: AI timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T16_E1 element_type: Interaction_Marker extraction_confidence: High content: "Acknowledges instruction and generates Project Charter v1.0." attributes: { interaction_type: Acknowledgment } links: [ { target_id: T15_E2, link_type: Responds_To } ] - element_id: T16_E2 element_type: Reference_Mention extraction_confidence: High content: "Generated Project Charter v1.0 content." attributes: { reference_type: Other, stated_purpose: Output_Data } # Output_Data is implied links: [ { target_id: T15_E2, link_type: Generates } ] - turn_id: T17 speaker: User timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T17_E1 element_type: Interaction_Marker extraction_confidence: High content: "States they haven't seen the charter and requests it be shown." attributes: { interaction_type: Clarification_Request } # Or Request_Action links: [ { target_id: T16_E2, link_type: Seeks_Clarification_Of } ] # Or Refers_To - turn_id: T18 speaker: AI timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T18_E1 element_type: Interaction_Marker extraction_confidence: High content: "Apologizes for oversight." attributes: { interaction_type: Apology } links: [ { target_id: T17_E1, link_type: Responds_To } ] - element_id: T18_E2 element_type: Reference_Mention extraction_confidence: High content: "Displays Project Charter v1.0 content." attributes: { reference_type: Other, stated_purpose: Output_Data } # Output_Data is implied links: [ { target_id: T17_E1, link_type: Responds_To } ] # Provides the requested info - turn_id: T19 speaker: User timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T19_E1 element_type: Interaction_Marker extraction_confidence: High content: "Approves charter v1.0." attributes: { interaction_type: Approval, target_element_id: T18_E2 } links: [ { target_id: T18_E2, link_type: Approves } ] - element_id: T19_E2 element_type: Interaction_Marker extraction_confidence: High content: "Requests assignment of project code and generation of final charter." attributes: { interaction_type: Request_Action } links: [ { target_id: T19_E1, link_type: Builds_Upon } ] - turn_id: T20 speaker: AI timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T20_E1 element_type: Interaction_Marker extraction_confidence: High content: "Acknowledges approval and request." attributes: { interaction_type: Acknowledgment } links: [ { target_id: T19_E1, link_type: Responds_To }, { target_id: T19_E2, link_type: Responds_To } ] - element_id: T20_E2 element_type: Assertion extraction_confidence: High content: "Assigns project code ICE." attributes: { assertion_type: Observation, evidence_cited: None, stance_expressed: Neutral, stance_strength: Unspecified, confidence_expressed: High, argument_id: Null } links: [ { target_id: T19_E2, link_type: Responds_To } ] - element_id: T20_E3 element_type: Reference_Mention extraction_confidence: High content: "Generates Project Charter v1.1 content." attributes: { reference_type: Other, stated_purpose: Output_Data } # Output_Data is implied links: [ { target_id: T19_E2, link_type: Generates } ] - element_id: T20_E4 element_type: Question extraction_confidence: High content: "Asks user for next step/focus area." attributes: { question_type: Open_Ended, answer_status: Unanswered } links: [ { target_id: T20_E3, link_type: Builds_Upon } ] - turn_id: T21 speaker: User timestamp: Null elements: - element_id: T21_E1 element_type: Interaction_Marker extraction_confidence: High content: "Requests YAML frontmatter for the charter file." attributes: { interaction_type: Request_Action } links: [ { target_id: T20_E3, link_type: Refers_To } ] # Refers to the generated charter content # ---- FINAL STATE SUMMARY ---- # Reflects the state at the end of the processed scope final_state: open_question_ids: [ T20_E4 ] # AI asked for next step stated_conclusion_ids: [ T20_E3 ] # The finalized Project Charter v1.1 represents a conclusion of that sub-task unresolved_topic_descriptions: [ "Next steps/focus area for Project ICE" ] detected_conflict_ids: [] processing_issues: [] # ---- CONVERSATION LOG END ----