plan: version: '1.0' status: Formalized wbs: - id: '0.0' description: 'Phase 0: Foundational Synthesis & Knowledge Consolidation' parent_id: null dependencies: [] definition_of_done: All Phase 0 deliverables (Synthesis Doc, Refined Goals, Parking Lot, Charter v1.1) generated and approved by User. Readiness for subsequent phase planning confirmed. is_summary_task: true is_milestone: true produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Synthesis', 'User-Review'] estimated_duration: 'N/A (Completed)' actual_duration: 'N/A (Completed)' - id: '0.1' description: 'Systematic Review: AI processes all provided historical project files.' parent_id: '0.0' dependencies: [] definition_of_done: AI confirms processing of all relevant input files identified. Internal knowledge base updated. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: false status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Processing'] specialized_process_inputs: { source_files_list_reference: "/archive/projects/FID/source_collateral/" } ai_skill_to_invoke: "NoOp" # Represents internal processing - id: '0.2' description: 'Knowledge Extraction: AI extracts key elements.' parent_id: '0.0' dependencies: ['0.1'] definition_of_done: Structured data or internal representation of extracted knowledge created. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: false status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Analysis'] ai_skill_to_invoke: "NoOp" # Represents internal processing - id: '0.3' description: 'Identify Core Threads & Challenges: AI analyzes extracted knowledge.' parent_id: '0.0' dependencies: ['0.2'] definition_of_done: Internal analysis complete, key threads/challenges identified. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: false status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Analysis'] ai_skill_to_invoke: "NoOp" # Represents internal processing - id: '0.4' description: 'Synthesize Baseline Document: AI generates FID_Historical_Synthesis_v1.0.' parent_id: '0.0' dependencies: ['0.3'] definition_of_done: Draft synthesis document generated and approved by user. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Drafting', 'User-Review'] specialized_process_inputs: { topic: "FID Historical Context", output_filename_base: "FID_Historical_Synthesis_v1.0" } ai_skill_to_invoke: "DraftTextualContent" # Conceptual - id: '0.5' description: 'Refine Core Problem/Goals: AI proposes FID_Refined_Problem_Goals_v1.0.' parent_id: '0.0' dependencies: ['0.4'] definition_of_done: Draft refined goals document generated and approved by user. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Drafting', 'User-Review'] specialized_process_inputs: { source_document_ref: "FID_Historical_Synthesis_v1.0", output_filename_base: "FID_Refined_Problem_Goals_v1.0" } ai_skill_to_invoke: "DraftTextualContent" # Conceptual - id: '0.6' description: 'Update Parking Lot: AI generates FID_ParkingLot_v1.0.' parent_id: '0.0' dependencies: ['0.3'] definition_of_done: Draft parking lot document generated and approved by user. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Drafting', 'User-Review'] specialized_process_inputs: { source_analysis_ref: "project_state.analysis_results.skill_outputs[...]", output_filename_base: "FID_ParkingLot_v1.0" } # Placeholder ref ai_skill_to_invoke: "DraftTextualContent" # Conceptual - id: '0.7' description: 'Revise Charter: AI proposes FID_Charter_v1.1.' parent_id: '0.0' dependencies: ['0.5'] definition_of_done: Draft revised charter generated and approved by user. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Drafting', 'User-Review'] specialized_process_inputs: { base_charter_ref: "FID_Charter_v1.0", goals_ref: "FID_Refined_Problem_Goals_v1.0", output_filename_base: "FID_Charter_v1.1" } ai_skill_to_invoke: "DraftTextualContent" # Conceptual - id: '0.8' description: 'Phase 0 Review & Approval: User approves Phase 0 completion.' parent_id: '0.0' dependencies: ['0.4', '0.5', '0.6', '0.7'] definition_of_done: User explicitly approves all Phase 0 deliverables. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: true produces_human_deliverable: false status: Completed assigned_resources: ['User-Validation'] - id: '1.0' description: 'Phase 1: FID Layer 1 Concept Development' parent_id: null dependencies: ['0.8'] definition_of_done: FID L1 Conceptual Framework validated and documented. Decision on L2 readiness made. is_summary_task: true is_milestone: true produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Research', 'User-Validation'] estimated_duration: 'N/A (Completed)' actual_duration: 'N/A (Completed)' - id: '1.1' description: 'Re-validate/Refine PBRF L0 Axioms for FID Context' parent_id: '1.0' dependencies: ['0.8'] definition_of_done: Finalized FID L0 Axioms documented and approved. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false # Sub-milestone is 1.1.3 produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Analysis', 'User-Review'] - id: '1.1.1' description: 'Review PBRF L0 Axioms against FID Historical Synthesis & Refined Goals.' parent_id: '1.1' dependencies: ['0.8'] definition_of_done: Review complete, areas for potential refinement identified. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: false status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Analysis'] - id: '1.1.2' description: 'Propose necessary refinements/adaptations to L0 axioms for FID (Output: FID_L0_Axiom_Refinements_Proposal_v1.0).' parent_id: '1.1' dependencies: ['1.1.1'] definition_of_done: Proposed L0 refinements documented and approved. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Drafting', 'User-Review'] ai_skill_to_invoke: "DraftTextualContent" specialized_process_inputs: { content_topic_or_prompt: "Refinements for PBRF L0 Axioms for FID", source_material_references: ["FID_Historical_Synthesis_v1.0", "FID_Refined_Problem_Goals_v1.0", "/archive/projects/FID/source_collateral/projects/PBRF/0216_PBRF_Layer0_Axioms_v1.0"], output_filename_base: "FID_L0_Axiom_Refinements_Proposal_v1.0" } - id: '1.1.3' description: 'Document Finalized FID L0 Axioms (Output: FID_L0_Axioms_v1.0).' parent_id: '1.1' dependencies: ['1.1.2'] definition_of_done: FID_L0_Axioms_v1.0 generated and approved. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: true produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Drafting', 'User-Review'] ai_skill_to_invoke: "DraftTextualContent" specialized_process_inputs: { content_topic_or_prompt: "Finalized FID L0 Axioms", source_material_references: ["FID_L0_Axiom_Refinements_Proposal_v1.0", "/archive/projects/FID/source_collateral/projects/PBRF/0216_PBRF_Layer0_Axioms_v1.0"], output_filename_base: "FID_L0_Axioms_v1.0" } - id: '1.2' description: 'Derive FID Layer 1 Conceptual Framework' parent_id: '1.0' dependencies: ['1.1.3'] definition_of_done: All core L1 concepts and qualitative mechanisms derived from FID L0 and documented. is_summary_task: false # Parent 1.0 is summary is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Research', 'User-Review'] - id: '1.2.1' description: 'Define L1 Concepts - Core Dynamics (Output: FID_L1_Concepts_Dynamics_v1.0).' parent_id: '1.2' dependencies: ['1.1.3'] definition_of_done: FID_L1_Concepts_Dynamics_v1.0 generated and approved. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Drafting', 'User-Review'] ai_skill_to_invoke: "DraftTextualContent" specialized_process_inputs: { content_topic_or_prompt: "FID L1 Concepts: Core Dynamics", source_material_references: ["FID_L0_Axioms_v1.0"], output_filename_base: "FID_L1_Concepts_Dynamics_v1.0" } - id: '1.2.2' description: 'Define L1 Concepts - Emergent Structure & Stability (Output: FID_L1_Concepts_Structure_v1.0).' parent_id: '1.2' dependencies: ['1.1.3'] definition_of_done: FID_L1_Concepts_Structure_v1.0 generated and approved. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Drafting', 'User-Review'] ai_skill_to_invoke: "DraftTextualContent" specialized_process_inputs: { content_topic_or_prompt: "FID L1 Concepts: Emergent Structure & Stability", source_material_references: ["FID_L0_Axioms_v1.0"], output_filename_base: "FID_L1_Concepts_Structure_v1.0" } - id: '1.2.3' description: 'Define L1 Concepts - Interaction & Influence (Output: FID_L1_Concepts_Interaction_v1.0).' parent_id: '1.2' dependencies: ['1.1.3'] definition_of_done: FID_L1_Concepts_Interaction_v1.0 generated and approved. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Drafting', 'User-Review'] ai_skill_to_invoke: "DraftTextualContent" specialized_process_inputs: { content_topic_or_prompt: "FID L1 Concepts: Interaction & Influence", source_material_references: ["FID_L0_Axioms_v1.0"], output_filename_base: "FID_L1_Concepts_Interaction_v1.0" } - id: '1.2.4' description: 'Derive Qualitative Mechanisms for generic reality features (Output: FID_L1_Mechanisms_v1.0).' parent_id: '1.2' dependencies: ['1.2.1', '1.2.2', '1.2.3'] definition_of_done: FID_L1_Mechanisms_v1.0 generated and approved. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Drafting', 'User-Review'] ai_skill_to_invoke: "DraftTextualContent" specialized_process_inputs: { content_topic_or_prompt: "FID L1 Qualitative Mechanisms", source_material_references: ["FID_L0_Axioms_v1.0", "FID_L1_Concepts_Dynamics_v1.0", "FID_L1_Concepts_Structure_v1.0", "FID_L1_Concepts_Interaction_v1.0"], output_filename_base: "FID_L1_Mechanisms_v1.0" } - id: '1.3' description: 'FID Layer 1 Internal Assessment & URFE Preparation' parent_id: '1.0' dependencies: ['1.2'] # Depends on all L1 concepts being defined definition_of_done: Internal consistency checks documented; Draft L1 URFE response generated. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Analysis', 'User-Review'] - id: '1.3.1' description: 'Perform internal consistency checks and adversarial thought experiments on FID L1.' parent_id: '1.3' dependencies: ['1.2'] definition_of_done: Assessment documented. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Critique'] ai_skill_to_invoke: "CritiqueArtifact" specialized_process_inputs: { artifact_reference: "FID L1 Conceptual Framework (all docs 1.2.1-1.2.4)", critique_focus_areas: ["Internal Consistency", "Alignment with L0", "Explanatory Power for URFE questions"], output_filename_base: "FID_L1_InternalAssessment_v1.0" } - id: '1.3.2' description: 'Draft FID L1 URFE Response (Output: FID_L1_URFE_Response_Draft_v1.0).' parent_id: '1.3' dependencies: ['1.3.1'] definition_of_done: FID_L1_URFE_Response_Draft_v1.0 generated and approved. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: true status: Completed assigned_resources: ['AI-Drafting', 'User-Review'] ai_skill_to_invoke: "DraftTextualContent" specialized_process_inputs: { content_topic_or_prompt: "FID L1 URFE Response", source_material_references: ["FID_L0_Axioms_v1.0", "FID_L1_Concepts_Dynamics_v1.0", "FID_L1_Concepts_Structure_v1.0", "FID_L1_Concepts_Interaction_v1.0", "FID_L1_Mechanisms_v1.0", "/archive/projects/FID/source_collateral/Ultimate Reality Framework Examination"], output_filename_base: "FID_L1_URFE_Response_Draft_v1.0" } - id: '1.4' description: '(Milestone) FID L1 Conceptual Framework Validation' parent_id: '1.0' dependencies: ['1.3'] definition_of_done: User reviews all L1 deliverables and approves L1 validation. Decision on L2 readiness made and logged. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: true produces_human_deliverable: false # User action status: Completed assigned_resources: ['User-Validation'] - id: '2.0' description: 'Phase 2: L2 Formalism Search & Definition' parent_id: null dependencies: ['1.4'] definition_of_done: Primary L2 formalism selected, defined, and validated against L2 criteria (PBRF SC2.1-SC2.4). is_summary_task: true is_milestone: true produces_human_deliverable: true status: Not Started assigned_resources: ['AI-Research', 'User-Guidance', 'User-Validation'] estimated_duration: 'Significant research effort' - id: '2.1' description: 'Define L2 Formalism Requirements' parent_id: '2.0' dependencies: ['1.4'] definition_of_done: Document detailing L2 requirements (must embody L0/L1, support structure emergence, EQR grounding, testability) generated and approved. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: true status: Not Started assigned_resources: ['AI-Drafting', 'User-Review'] ai_skill_to_invoke: "DraftTextualContent" specialized_process_inputs: { content_topic_or_prompt: "FID L2 Formalism Requirements", source_material_references: ["FID_L0_Axioms_v1.0", "FID_L1_Conceptual_Framework (all docs)", "FID_Charter_v1.1 (Goal 2, EQR)"], output_filename_base: "FID_L2_Requirements_v1.0" } - id: '2.2' description: 'Survey & Evaluate Candidate Formalisms' parent_id: '2.0' dependencies: ['2.1'] definition_of_done: Survey of potential formalisms (e.g., advanced network theory, GA, process calculus, DCIN NBM context) and evaluation against L2 requirements documented. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: true status: Not Started assigned_resources: ['AI-Research', 'User-Input'] ai_skill_to_invoke: "ConductFullLiteratureReview" # Conceptual, or series of targeted searches specialized_process_inputs: { topic: "Mathematical/Computational Formalisms for Emergent Physics from Informational Principles", scope_description: "Formalisms capable of meeting FID_L2_Requirements_v1.0", output_filename_base: "FID_L2_FormalismSurvey_v1.0" } - id: '2.3' description: 'Select Primary L2 Formalism Candidate(s)' parent_id: '2.0' dependencies: ['2.2'] definition_of_done: Decision on primary candidate(s) made and documented with rationale. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: true # Key decision produces_human_deliverable: true # Decision document status: Not Started assigned_resources: ['User-Decision', 'AI-AnalysisSupport'] ai_skill_to_invoke: "LogDecisions" # After user makes decision specialized_process_inputs: { decision_made_reference: "User input on L2 formalism selection", rationale_reference: "User input and FID_L2_FormalismSurvey_v1.0 evaluation" } - id: '2.4' description: 'Develop/Refine Specific L2 Formalism Definition (Iterative)' parent_id: '2.0' dependencies: ['2.3'] definition_of_done: Detailed mathematical/computational definition of the chosen L2 formalism documented. is_summary_task: false is_milestone: false produces_human_deliverable: true status: Not Started assigned_resources: ['AI-Development', 'User-Guidance'] estimated_duration: 'Multi-sprint' # ai_skill_to_invoke: "DraftTextualContent" or more specialized modeling skill specialized_process_inputs: { content_topic_or_prompt: "Detailed definition of selected L2 Formalism for FID", source_material_references: ["FID_L2_Requirements_v1.0", "Selected Formalism Documentation"], output_filename_base: "FID_L2_Formalism_Definition_vX.Y" } - id: '2.5' description: '(Milestone) Validate L2 Formalism Definition' parent_id: '2.0' dependencies: ['2.4'] definition_of_done: L2 Formalism definition validated against PBRF SC2.1-SC2.4 (specific, justified embodiment of L0/L1, consistent, represents concepts). is_summary_task: false is_milestone: true produces_human_deliverable: true # Validation report status: Not Started assigned_resources: ['AI-Critique', 'User-Validation'] ai_skill_to_invoke: "CritiqueArtifact" specialized_process_inputs: { artifact_reference: "FID_L2_Formalism_Definition_vX.Y", critique_criteria_reference: "PBRF_Success_Criteria (SC2.1-SC2.4)", output_filename_base: "FID_L2_ValidationReport_v1.0" } - id: '3.0' description: 'Phase 3: L3 Modeling & Validation (Emergence & EQR)' parent_id: null dependencies: ['2.5'] definition_of_done: L2 formalism implemented; emergence of structures and EQR compatibility tested and validated against PBRF SC3.1-SC3.5. is_summary_task: true is_milestone: true produces_human_deliverable: true status: Not Started assigned_resources: ['AI-Development', 'AI-Simulation', 'User-Validation'] estimated_duration: 'Significant research effort' # ... (Placeholder tasks for L3: Implement L2, Test Emergence, Test EQR, Validate L3) ... - id: '4.0' description: 'Phase 4: Novel Predictions & PEAP Application' parent_id: null dependencies: ['3.0'] # Assuming L3 validation is a prerequisite definition_of_done: Novel predictions derived, PEAP applied, outcomes documented. is_summary_task: true is_milestone: true produces_human_deliverable: true status: Not Started assigned_resources: ['AI-Analysis', 'User-Guidance', 'User-Validation'] estimated_duration: 'Significant research effort' # ... (Placeholder tasks for L4: Derive Predictions, Apply PEAP, Classify, Propose Tests, Review) ... - id: '5.0' description: 'Phase 5: Final Synthesis, Unification, and Reporting' parent_id: null dependencies: ['4.0'] definition_of_done: Final FID framework documented, explanatory power assessed, project closed or next steps defined. is_summary_task: true is_milestone: true produces_human_deliverable: true status: Not Started assigned_resources: ['AI-Drafting', 'User-Review'] estimated_duration: 'Multi-sprint' # ... (Placeholder tasks for L5: Synthesize Framework, Analyze Parsimony, Draft Final Report, Project Closure) ... task_sequencing_notes: Work proceeds sequentially through Phases (0-5). Tasks within phases have specified dependencies. Validation milestones gate progress. resource_plan_notes: Primary resource is User-AI collaboration. Computational resources for L3 simulations. Access to historical PBRF/EQR/Infomatics detailed docs if L2/L3 builds directly on them. quality_plan_notes: Adherence to PBRF OMF v2.0, FID KAs (StyleGuide, Glossary, SuccessMetrics). Layered validation against PBRF Success Criteria. PEAP for novel predictions. Rigorous self-critique (Meta-RefineOutput) by AI for key generated artifacts. risk_register: - id: R01 description: Substrate/Dynamics Definition - Failure to define L0/L1/L2 that robustly generates stable, diverse emergent structures. likelihood: High impact: Critical response_strategy: PBRF OMF layered validation, fail-fast, learning from Synthesis. owner: AI/User status: Open - id: R02 description: EQR Grounding - Inability to derive/integrate EQR v1.0. likelihood: Medium-High impact: High response_strategy: Core L2/L3 requirement; iterative refinement of L2/L3 or EQR understanding. owner: AI/User status: Open - id: R03 description: Formalism Intractability - L2 proves analytically or computationally intractable for L3 validation. likelihood: Medium impact: High response_strategy: Early feasibility checks in L2 development, modular L2 design, focus on qualitative/structural validation initially. owner: AI/User status: Open - id: R04 description: Novel Prediction Interpretation - Difficulty in rigorously applying PEAP to distinguish genuine novel predictions from model flaws, or in convincing the broader scientific community. likelihood: High impact: High response_strategy: Extreme rigor in PEAP steps (IRC, BCA, CEPU); clear articulation of critique of conventional benchmarks; focus on proposing decisive verification paths. owner: AI/User status: Open - id: R05 description: Paradigm Inertia - Resistance from conventional scientific viewpoints to consider challenges to established models. likelihood: Very High impact: Medium # On external acceptance, not internal validity response_strategy: Focus on rigorous internal consistency, clear articulation of explanatory advantages, and proposing compelling empirical tests. owner: User status: Open change_management_process: Significant changes to scope, goals, or methodology require explicit user approval and documentation update (e.g., Charter/Plan revision). Decisions made during sprints logged in `project_state.logs.decisions`. methodology_specific_planning: Governed by PBRF OMF v2.0, emphasizing layered development, principle-first derivation, explicit success criteria (PBRF Success Criteria), fail-fast/pivot cycles, and PEAP for novel predictions. internal_review_summary: "Plan drafted based on PBRF OMF structure, covering all FID Charter goals through 5 distinct phases. Phases 0 & 1 reflect completed re-processing of historical work. Phases 2-5 outline new work for L2 formalism, L3 emergence, L4 novel predictions (with PEAP), and L5 final synthesis. Key decision: Structuring PEAP as a distinct phase (L4) for emphasis. WBS tasks assigned AI skills where appropriate. Durations are high-level estimates." flagged_critical_issues: []